syphilaids
As played, I ship.
You are a 6.6:1 dog IF either player has a set. I think due to the fact that it's a live game You can't just assume there MUST be a set. 2 pair+ I would say is reasonable, but in a live game I'm most affraid of 34 here.
80% of the time I'd say our J's are good as well as spades. Assuming the best hand here is A5, It's an easy call.
There's a lot we draw well (Ax), a lot we draw slim to (straight/sets/AJ), and even some we dominate (5s6s, QJ, etc.)
combine these and I believe the call is +EV
Personally, I'd much rather check/call or check/fold the turn depending on the action, given that 3 people called your reraise. Either this, or just Ship the turn.