the odds of finishing 1st in all three is (1/1737)(1/5636)(1/35594) 1 in 348,455,720,808
If this is true 348 billion with approximately 52 Sundays in a year means this is to happen once every 6.7 billion years, maybe 6billion if you account for him being a skilled (but unknown) player?
Seems implausible given stars has only been operating since 9/11/03
There is the explanation of "there is always a chance" and the idea that there are other anomalies that could happen... but I still highly suspect that this is VERY unnatural. At some point the odds just out weigh the reality of it. I dunno, will be interesting to see if any evidence comes out to support the legitimacy of it.